THE NARRATIVE IDENTITY CRISIS OF RED (TAYLOR'S VERSION)
Not Just A Breakup Album...
With Red, Taylor Swift launched an emotionally raw and thematically complex era, one marked by heartache, memory, and self-reclamation. While her previous albums dealt with young love and wide-eyed innocence, Red saw Swift diving into much deeper waters, confronting not just loss but the psychological dynamics that can distort one’s reality and erode identity at the core. At its heart, Red is an album about trying to find meaning in what happened, and looking back and realizing that some of the most vivid moments in our lives are also the most painful to narrate.
In Taylor Swift and Philosophy, the song “All Too Well (Taylor’s Version)” becomes a centerpiece for examining the philosophical and emotional experience of gaslighting. In the now-iconic All Too Well: The Short Film, Swift gives us a scene in which the protagonist expresses discomfort after a dinner with older people. Her much older partner dismisses her concerns, saying, “I think you’re making yourself feel that way.” This moment illustrates a textbook example of gaslighting: invalidating someone’s emotions to the point where they begin to doubt their own reality.
Gaslight, Gatekeep, Girl Reclaim
As the book explains, the victim of gaslighting begins to defer to the gaslighter's perception, questioning her own thoughts, feelings, and memories. Swift’s lyrics reflect this experience with haunting clarity. Her songs are not just storytelling, they’re acts of resistance, reclaiming the right to interpret her own life and feelings. When she sings, “I’d like to be my old self again / But I’m still trying to find it,” she is acknowledging the damage done by emotional manipulation and the struggle to reconstruct a coherent sense of self in the aftermath.
Taylor Swift and The Philosophy of Self
This process ties closely to the philosophical idea of narrative identity, explored in the work of philosopher Marya Schechtman. According to Schechtman, we make sense of who we are by creating a story out of the events we live through. Some moments become central to our narrative identity—while others fade into the background. Swift’s music, especially on Red, can be seen as a process of building that narrative. Each song is an episode in the story of who she is, shaped by what she chooses to remember, highlight, or mourn.
​
In The Moment I Knew (Taylor’s Version), she sings, “People ask me how I’ve been / As I comb back through my memory,” offering a glimpse into how reflection becomes self-creation. Memory is not just passive, it’s an active process of reconstruction. Swift shows us how the act of revisiting the past, painful as it may be, is essential to reclaiming authorship over our own stories.
Conclusion
Red isn’t just about heartbreak. It’s about the recovery of self—piecing together identity in the wake of emotional chaos. It’s about confronting the episodes we wish we could forget and choosing to write them into our personal narrative anyway, because they matter. They shaped us. As fans, we are drawn to this honesty, this unfiltered attempt at making meaning out of confusion.
Philosophically, Red invites us to think about who we are not just as people who feel, but as people who tell stories about what we feel, who strive to understand and own those stories. In doing so, Swift reminds us that pain is not the end of the story, it's part of the process of becoming.