_Logo_2014.webp){kind=logo}
1989: Rebirth, Reinvention, and the Harsh Criticism That Comes With It
In 2014, Taylor Swift pushed the boundaries. With the release of her fifth studio album, 1989, she went all-in on pop music, abandoning country roots that had marked her early career. As she described it, 1989 was her "very first, documented, official pop album." Overall, it was not simply a genre transition, it was a transformation. A ‘rebirth’.
 |  |
|---|---|
 |  |
 |  |
 |  |
 |  |
 |  |
Committed to her birth year, 1989 was a new beginning for Swift: more self-aware, more self-assured, and more bold. In Taylor Swift and Philosophy, the transformation is not merely musical - it's existential. The polished pop sound of the album and the themes of independence, resilience, and self-recapture are the construction of a new self, both for Swift and for her listeners.
Blank Space and the Critique of Public Persona
But with reinvention and success came the harsh reality. The more successful you are, the more intense the glare of criticism. Swift suffered a relentless, sometimes cruel public scrutiny. She was probed with gossip about her romantic life, dubbed "annoying," ridiculed over her friendships, and ceaselessly psychoanalyzed about her body. She was both skinny-shamed and fat-shamed in response. Her image, her personality, her music - nothing was off-limits.
Nowhere does she respond better to this criticism than in the song Blank Space. Rather than refute the media portrayal of her as a "serial dater" or hopeless romantic, Swift doubled down on the narrative with satire. "Got a long list of ex-lovers / They'll tell you I'm insane," she sings, winking at the tabloids. In Taylor Swift and Philosophy, it's a master move philosophically of sorts: Swift fights back narrative ownership over her life by over-amping it, converting criticism to creativity. She reconstructs not only her songs, but the narratives themselves employed against her.
Philosophically, 1989 might be read as a reaction against that judgment. Songs like "Shake It Off" or "Blank Space" do more than get stuck in your head; they are assertions of identity in the face of judgment.
Blank Space is not only an intelligent song, it's an instance of self-authorship. Swift reworks the cultural story, showing how fast women, especially public women, are cut down to trope. The melodramatic staging of the "crazy girlfriend" trope within the song doesn't feed it - it undercuts it by making it so perversely over-the-top that it can't be seriously considered.
Conclusion
Taylor Swift didn't just alter her sound in 1989 - she recharted the terms of her public life. With deliberate artistry and self-awareness, she confronted criticism not with retreat, but with makeover; a reinvention. As Taylor Swift and Philosophy makes apparent, her music is not just entertainment - it's a philosophical stance. 1989 is not just a pop album; it's a self-fashioning manifesto in the age of perpetual surveillance and criticism.